Things heated up when she heard Weber and Sluss were “having troubles” in January 2020. By February, the pair met up at a Bachelor Nation engagement party and ended up leaving together. “He was like, ‘I have so much to tell you,’” Brown said.
In her book she explained that they slept together before Brown learned he was having thoughts about Prewett. “The chemistry just wasn’t there,” she said. “It just sucked. And then I found out he had another girl on his mind. It was all so bizarre.”
On November 18, Peter Weber responded to Brown’s exposé on his podcast, Bachelors in the City. “I thought we were just going to keep it private, but I guess that wasn’t the case,” he said, per People. “And I’m totally okay with it; it’s all good. I don’t mind any of this.”
As Weber recalls, Bachelor producers actually warned him not to attend the engagement party because Brown would be in attendance, but he went anyway. “I ended up leaving [the party] and then I was like, ‘I want to talk to [Brown] more,’” he said. “I remember I pulled over, I texted her, and I was like, ‘Hey, let’s chat. You want to talk more?’ And so I ended up coming back to the party and she snuck out of the house without anyone figuring out and got in my car.”
In the end, he agreed that their hookup “wasn’t the same as I think we had originally felt,” but he harbors no ill will. He said, “Obviously I wish her all the success and all the support and I guess now our little secret’s out there.”